Reply To: 20 Years Ago: Gary Cherone Leaves Van Halen

VH3 has some really nice moments, buried in a lot of junk. I think the biggest issue was the album was wwaaaaayyyyyy over-produced. I completely blame Eddie for that. I always thought Gary was never given a fair shot. To me a lot of VH3 felt forced. They should have spent more time with each other and built chemistry. Just my humble opinion.